Best Value Home Renovations
Over dinner last night the topic of what the best return on investment renovations were and I went with the generally accepted addition of a full bathroom as the highest return. After scouring the internet, I found this great site that listed their opinions - I’m inclined to believe, if not the absolute numbers, that their relative place on the list is probably accurate. Tops is the addition of a full 2nd bathroom, average cost of $12k, and a payback of 100%. The worse is to finish the basement, which my friend correctly identified, at a cost of approximately $8k and an average 15% return.
This is the table, with some items removed (which I thought you couldn’t accurately quantify, like landscaping is so broad), from the site:
| Home Improvement | Avg. Cost | Return % |
|---|---|---|
| Finish a Basement | $8,000 | 15% |
| Build a Swimming Pool | $10,000 | 25% |
| Add a Garage | $15,000 | 40% |
| Replace Roof | $6,000 | 50% |
| Replace Siding | $10,000 | 60% |
| Sunroom | $25,000 | 60% |
| Home Office | $6,000 | 60% |
| Bathroom Remodel | $7,000 | 70% |
| Replace Windows | $6,000 | 70% |
| Add a Fireplace | $3,000 | 75% |
| Add a Deck | $6,000 | 80% |
| Kitchen Remodel Major | $30,000 | 80% |
| Kitchen Remodel Minor | $8,000 | 90% |
| Attic Bedroom | $10,000 | 90% |
| Add 2nd Full Bathroom | $12,000 | 100% |
The article they have written is very good, I suggest you read it, because it puts some substance behind the numbers and the article makes good sense. Ultimately though, they say that you shouldn’t go by ROI as your reasons for the improvements. If you will enjoy it aesthetically or it will bring happiness to you personally if you have the improvement done, then you should value that more than its ability to increase your home’s value.
8 responses to “Best Value Home Renovations”
Matt responds:
Posted: July 30th, 2005 at 7:11 am
In other words, unless you’re planning on selling in the immediate future, most of the value of a home renovation is not denominated in cash.
The items on the bottom (that is, the lowest-returning ones) kind of surprise me. But the easy ability of an added bathroom or bedroom to translate into higher sale prices is pretty obvious.
jim says in reply:
Posted: July 30th, 2005 at 11:48 am
Exactly, this is a good guide for people who want to “quickly” boost their home’s value through improvements (not repairs). I was very surprised a finished basement only nets you, on average, only a 15% return. I think you’ll see a higher return if you place is smaller overall (reported square footage of a home is only finished square footage, so you get a boost in total living space if you finish the basement) and the basement is an important living space.
For example, in my townhouse, the basement is very important. But in many two story single family homes, the basement is an afterthought/storage area. Finishing a storage area probably won’t get you very much.
Consumerism Commentary responds:
Posted: August 8th, 2005 at 5:41 am
Carnival of Personal Finance #8
Welcome to this week’s Carnival of Personal Finance (basic introduction, schedule) and welcome to Consumerism Commentary (about, best of) to any new readers! This is the eighth installment of the Carnival. In this issue: Designer Pets. Free Money…
Matt responds:
Posted: August 9th, 2005 at 4:36 am
On further reflection, my working hypothesis is that the highest-returning home improvements are that way less because of increasing the value of a house to any given prospective buyer than by attracting additional buyers with higher pricing expectations…which, given the nature of the housing market, will naturally tend to be a more effective way to increase the sale price.
jim says in reply:
Posted: August 9th, 2005 at 7:21 am
Matt, that’s an interesting point you make (which I agree with) and it also increases the expectations of a house. A 2 bedroom, 1 bath place isn’t even on most people’s radar (people put a premium on having their own full bathroom) but a 2 bedroom, 2 bath place is - so you’re effectively increasing the demand by adding the bathroom and not necessarily actually increasing the home’s value by the cost of the project.
» Most Requested Home Features Not Best Value by Blueprint for Financial Prosperity responds:
Posted: August 30th, 2005 at 3:08 pm
[...] CNNMoney printed an article today on the most requested home improvement proejcts and topping the list were, in order of popularity, home office, game room, and a mud room. In terms of best value, these three aren’t the best value. Only home office appears on the list of best valued home improvements (60% return) but it goes to show that people don’t pick what the best dollar return improvement, they pick the one they’ll enjoy the most. (something pointed out in the best value article as what should be driving your improvement decisions anyway) [...]
Caitlin responds:
Posted: August 31st, 2005 at 9:54 pm
I know those are average prices but….wow those are way way lower than Boston area costs to do comparable work. Boy would I love to add an attic bedroom for only $10k. Sigh. (the stairs alone would probably cost me that). I wonder about the affect of passing time on these returns (ie. if a major kitchen remodel is 5 years old, how has the return diminshed)
R. L. Shattuck responds:
Posted: December 18th, 2006 at 12:20 pm
Where in the world did you come up with your average remodeling costs listed on this page?
I’m betting that the links I see listed on this same page wouldn’t touch a basement finish or remodel for $8,000. and these people probably pay you to park their link on this page.
HELLO, If you go low-mid quality on material to finish a basement your going to have to spend somewhere between four and five grand to get it complete! What’s that leave for the craftsman/tradesman to install?
IT SIMPLY DOESN’T MAKE SENSE AND YOUR NUMBERS ARE NOT ACCURATE!
I have two very good friends who are mortgage agents and my girlfriend is a realtor, trust me, your numbers do not reflect an accurate return either!