Internet Sales Tax: State Deals with Amazon Bring Up Questions of Who Should Pay

Email  Print Print  

Amazon Internet sales taxIn September 2011, Amazon reached a deal with the State of California, which had been trying to get the retailer to collect sales tax on items shipped to the state. The agreement is that Amazon will start collecting sales tax in a year. Other states are making similar demands of Amazon, including Tennessee, which will require Amazon to begin collecting sales tax in 2014, and South Carolina is giving Amazon five years before it has to begin collecting sales tax on products bought by residents.

Of course, all of this could become moot if Congress gets involved — which is what many retailers want. Many retailers, from small mom and pop shops to retail giants like WalMart, want online retailers to begin collecting sales tax, since being sales-tax-free is yet another advantage that online sellers have over their brick-and-mortar counterparts. All of this talk of Amazon, Internet sales tax and possible Federal involvement has many wondering what the rules are for Internet sales tax.

Who Has to Collect Internet Sales Tax?

Back in 1992, the Supreme Court ruled that mail-order retailers weren’t required to collect sales tax in states where they don’t have a physical presence. Online retailers took this to apply to them as well. So, if you buy something from an online store that doesn’t have a brick-and-mortar presence in your state, that store doesn’t have to collect sales tax to send along to your state. Some states are part of an alliance, the Streamlined Sales & Use Tax Project, that have made it easier to collect sales tax from merchants — and consumers, and many retailers collect sales tax as a result (even though they don’t have to in the strictest sense).

Of course, if you buy something online from someone with a physical presence in your state, you do have to pay sales tax on it. Right now, it’s the physical presence that matters (unless you live in a state that has an agreement with Amazon, and other other retailers, to collect sales tax).

Paying a Use Tax on Items You Buy from Out of State Sellers

Of course, sales tax is a big source of revenue for most states, and they don’t want to miss out on that just because you are buying items out of state. Just because the merchants aren’t required to collect sales tax doesn’t mean that you aren’t supposed to pay it. When a consumer reports the sales tax he or she should have paid on out of state items, it’s called a use tax. You will notice, on some state income tax forms, that there is a line for you to list what you owe so you can pay it.

Bottom Line

States want revenue from taxes related to online sales, and they are beginning to crack down — especially as online shopping grows in popularity. States know that it is tough to get individuals to report their online purchases and pay the use tax, so they are concentrating on big online retailers, and even hoping that the 1992 Supreme Court decision about a required physical presence to be overturned. Until something happens on the federal level, though, we are likely to continue to see sales tax agreements between Amazon on individual states, as well as efforts to encourage online retailers to collect sales tax on purchases.

(Photo: thisisbossi)

{ 5 comments, please add your thoughts now! }

Related Posts

RSS Subscribe Like this article? Get all the latest articles sent to your email for free every day. Enter your email address and click "Subscribe." Your email will only be used for this daily subscription and you can unsubscribe anytime.

5 Responses to “Internet Sales Tax: State Deals with Amazon Bring Up Questions of Who Should Pay”

  1. Sun says:

    The whole idea of “internet sales tax” is stupid. Like you stated, use tax laws are already in place for tax collection. The states are just being lazy by not figuring out a way to collect from individuals. Instead, they are making the tax code even more complicated by adding a layer on top which is completely unnecessary. There are simple ways to automate tax collection, but I think government officials are not tech savvy and banks completely want to put up a wall.

    Here’s a simple solution for California with Amazon. Every tax jurisdiction (local) and state sign up a bank account with Amazon. When Amazon sells a sales tax eligible product to something shipped to California, you do a three way split on the total:

    1) local district, say Los Angeles, get their tax rate of 1.5%

    2) state gets their 7.25%

    3) Amazon gets to keep the rest after they split the payment

    … Figuring out the tax rate that corresponds to the ship to is not perfect 100% of the time, but they have systems like Avalara that can figure that out for you. If Amazon doesn’t want to pay for the cost, the states could pay the implementation and subscription for Amazon. The benefit is that the government collects tax on a daily basis (cash flow anyone?!) and they will collect tax upfront without trying to get it from each individual.

    We don’t need Streamlined Sales Tax (SST) or Internet Sales Tax.

    Enforce the laws that are already in place using technology that is currently available to make this possible.

    Its not difficult to do…

  2. Scott says:

    For a future post, it might be interesting to explore the moral and ethical aspects of paying sales tax as “required” on some state income tax returns.

    I live in SC and our state returns ask to include online purchases not taxed in order to pay those sales taxes. My wife and I have decided it is the right, ethical thing to do to report and pay those taxes. We have been doing it for years.

    However, we cannot seem to find anyone else, even fellow Christians, who are doing the same. I’m sure they are out there, but……

    What is the legal and ethical side of this, in your opinion?

  3. mannymacho says:

    I think if they want to collect the taxes they are going to have to set up a way to automatically collect it. We have time and again proven our laziness…we get income tax, payroll tax, and everything else automagically withdrawn…how on earth are we going to have the resolve to list down and add up all of the knick-knacks we buy online over the course of a year?

  4. Bart says:

    The right thing to do is to minimize the inefficient government system that will always demand more in taxes to cover ever constant overspending.

  5. travis says:

    I know this comment will get a lot of flack, but….

    Why does the states, cities, counties deserve taxes from companies like Amazon? In the states where they employ – they pay taxes, and business taxes.

    I’m no tax expert, but apart from giving the gov’t their cut for being there – what are these taxes doing?

Please Leave a Reply
Bargaineering Comment Policy

Previous Article: «
Next Article: »
Advertising Disclosure: Bargaineering may be compensated in exchange for featured placement of certain sponsored products and services, or your clicking on links posted on this website.
About | Contact Me | Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights | Terms of Use | Press
Copyright © 2016 by All rights reserved.