LifeLock Review

Email  Print Print  

Identity Theft On The RiseLifeLock is the company that has a picture of their CEO, Todd Davis, telling you his social security number is 457-55-5462 as a testament to the power of LifeLock’s services. It’s a marketing gimmick, no doubt, but it’s a pretty clever one, you have to admit.

However, the bottom line identity theft services like LifeLock is that you’re buying piece of mind and a maintenance service. You can do a majority of the services they provide, I outline them in Do-It-Yourself Identity Theft Protection, and they even freely admit this. With the exception of a $1 million service guarantee, everything else is free to the public.

You May Not Need It

If you are diligent, keep good records, and remember to do everything, I think you should do it yourself and not buy a service like LifeLock. If you aren’t and if you think you might be at risk for identity theft, it might be better to pay the $9 a month just so they do everything on-time and without lapses. They will remember to put fraud alerts on your credit history at the three bureaus every 90 days, they will remember to periodically refresh your data on so you stop getting junk mail, and they will request your credit history every 12 months from the three bureaus. It’s not a lot of work, but if you’re prone to lapses and forgetting to do things, $9 may be a fair amount to pay for someone to look over your shoulder. That’s why I think it’s more like a service contract (like when the heating company sends a technician out to check your HVAC every six months).

Since launching they’ve added several additional services including WalletLock (explained below), scanning black market forums for the sale of your identity, and other identity theft related activity.

Is Your Data Safe with LifeLock?

The first thing you have to consider is whether the company itself is safe, which is not an unreasonable reaction because of some of the negative stories out there about former founders and such. Here’s what they say: “LifeLock is ISO 27001 certified for data and operational security and follows industry best practices to secure and protect personal information. We conduct background checks on all of our employees, including regular random drug testing. All of our facilities are built with the latest biometric security access as well as state-of-the-art surveillance and alarm systems. No data is stored onsite. No computers anywhere outside of secure data centers have our member’s critical information on them.”

About The One Million Dollar Service Guarantee

One million dollars sounds like a lot but the figure is really just to put your mind at ease. The guarantee is that if your identity is stolen while you are a customer, Lifelock will pay for people to recover it, restore your losses, and recover any expenses. This is the insurance part of the Lifelock deal, it’s really piece of mind against the threat of identity theft. Is it worth it? It’s for you to decide how much you think the service of protecting you is worth and how much the insurance is worth, then work from there. Here is a link directly explaining their one million dollar service guarantee.


WalletLock is a service offered by LifeLock, included in the standard service package, that lets you call an 800-number if you ever find your wallet missing or stolen. LifeLock will then work with you to cancel credit cards, report stolen drivers’ licenses and social security cards, replace passports, visas, immigration documents, checkbooks, insurance cards, etc (you’ll have to identify them all via a form beforehand). The way to do this yourself is to photocopy all your credit cards, front and back, as well as all your other important documents so you have a copy if you lose the original. It also makes sense to indicate on your photocopies the cards you have in your purse and wallet so you know which ones to cancel. You could do this all yourself, or you could have it done for you included in the price.

American Express offers a similar service called the Credit Card Registry for $29/year. “American Express Credit Card Registry ensures a Cardmember’s cards will be protected. The service will cancel and request replacements of any lost or stolen cards (including ATM cards) – all with a single call. It also provides fraud liability coverage, passport replacement, and driver’s license replacement in several states… For more information, Cardmembers can call 1-800-227-2639.”

Bottom Line

The bottom line is that if you want identity theft protection, a service like LifeLock will give you that and more. Credit bureaus, and other companies, offer credit monitoring services that just look for abnormal activity. I think those services are a complete waste of money because they won’t protect you if something bad happens (and they often more expensive).

If you are diligent, do it yourself because you don’t need to pay someone $9 for something you’re able to stay on top of. If you aren’t diligent, these services aren’t a bad idea, just know that you’re essentially buying a service contract with someone keeping tabs on your identity and nothing something super special and fancy you wouldn’t otherwise be able to do. If you do sign up, be sure to get the 10% coupon floating around and you won’t pay full price (or click on the banner below).

I have not personally used LifeLock but they’re the company I always see in the news. Have you used them, or TrustedID or IdentityTruth, and want to share your experience; or do you see it as a waste of money?

(Photo: thetruthabout)

{ 12 comments, please add your thoughts now! }

Related Posts

RSS Subscribe Like this article? Get all the latest articles sent to your email for free every day. Enter your email address and click "Subscribe." Your email will only be used for this daily subscription and you can unsubscribe anytime.

12 Responses to “LifeLock Review”

  1. BankerBryan says:

    Thank you for this article, I hope more people opt to ‘do it yourself’ than rely on services like these. While they are convenient, the truth is – you can do it yourself.

    I’m always diligent when shopping online to make sure that I see httpS:// and a padlock on the screen, I don’t like giving my credit card information out any more than I have to. It’s not because I’m paranoid, it’s because I’ve had to have my cards replaced 3 times in the past 2 years due to compromises by big companies. The big companies that once promised me that my data would be secure.

    I just found out that one of my cards was compromised last week, so tally that up to 4 times in the past 2 years.

    The only person I can trust to keep my information secure – is me.

    • jim says:

      I think that’s the tradeoff – pay someone to do it or do it yourself. I personally don’t think $9 is a lot but it’s important to understand that you’re really paying someone to do something you’re doing yourself. If you understand that and are willing to pay the $9-$10 for these services, then I say more power to you.

  2. ross says:

    I’d be very careful recommending this company. There is a lot of shady history in at least one of the two partners. Robert J. Maynard (one of the partners) has been banned by the federal government from participating in the credit repair industry because his last company was found guilty of false advertising and deceptive practices.
    Here’s one link that digs into it.

    and here’s another article saying that lifelock customers in multiple states are suing because it doesn’t deliver what it promises.

    Some people may think the jury is still out on this ‘service’ but there is more than enough evidence for me to keep my wallet in my pocket.

    If you are really afraid if identity theft, then freeze your reports and monitor them on a frequent basis. Don’t put your trust in someone else to do it for you.

  3. ross says:

    Looks like you already got to it in a followup post.

    Fine reporting – on your part.
    Poor reading – on my part.
    Carry on, perhaps this comment will help reiterate the point to the ‘skimmers’ in your readership!

  4. LifeLock is an interesting service in that pretty much everything they do you can do yourself. Really what they are selling is peace of mind. For $10 a month, someone can feel like they are safe and protected by that guarantee. If you do it yourself, you may still feel like you are exposed. Now, don’t get me wrong, I’m a do-it-yourselfer but I see why many people would be attracted to this service.

  5. Kirk says:

    Jim, I couldn’t help but post this followup here. The idea of the service is a good one… too bad even Todd Davis himself still gets his identity stolen.

  6. Thomas Ryan says:

    Lifelock is a disaster. As a longtime Phoenix area resident I am all too familiar with their shenanigans.

    One would be wise to steer clear of this company as they have been dirty from day one!

    Don’t believe me? Read about how the Federal Trade Commission fined them for their shady practices.

  7. Margo Zargo says:

    My husband and I had Lifelock for years, and we paid them about $200 a year for both of us. Well, then my husband had his ID stolen, and they never alerted us to anything, we found out only when all of our banks and credit card companies called us. All Lifelock does is order a credit report for you once a year, and you can do this yourself at which is really free, not like the others that you see advertised on TV. Well, when I called Lifelock to ask them why they didn’t alert us. They told me that their service is only good if someone tries to Physically Impersonate you. Such as to go into a bank and try to get a loan claiming that they are you. I then canceled my service, and all the representative told me was “I’m sorry that you misunderstood what we offer”. I fell for their scam, and don’t you make the same expensive mistake that I did. Don’t get Lifelock, they do nothing to monitor your credit card fraud, which is what the crooks really use.

  8. CWatson says:

    My LifeLock was $18 per month, because I had chosen option to include spouse. They didn’t give me any hassle over the phone about cancelling. The just asked me why, and I told them ProtectMyID was offered free from AAA. User comments in got me to look at, but it appears that website is now defunct.

Please Leave a Reply
Bargaineering Comment Policy

Previous Article: «
Next Article: »
Advertising Disclosure: Bargaineering may be compensated in exchange for featured placement of certain sponsored products and services, or your clicking on links posted on this website.
About | Contact Me | Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights | Terms of Use | Press
Copyright © 2016 by All rights reserved.