comments
Nitrogen-Filled Tires & Better Gas Mileage?
Email
 Print
|
When I bought my tires from Costco, I noticed the caps for the valve stems were a flourescent green and asked about them – it means the tires are filled with Nitrogen. After reading a friend’s blog claiming that nitrogen-filled tires get 0.5 mi/gal better gas mileage and have a longer tire lifespan, I wanted to find some “proof” to these claims. The belief, also pushed by Costco in their tire brochures, is that the larger nitrogen molecules don’t react to temperature changes (better tread life and mileage) and lack moisture (won’t corrode the tire from the inside). It doesn’t affect my decision if these claims can’t be proven because there is a miniscule increased cost for using nitrogen (I can only “fill” my tires at a Costco, most gas stations only have air, but the service is free).
The theory is that the oxygen in the air inside the tire, when heated as a result of driving, can oxidize and rot the inside of the tire over time. A nitrogen filled tire won’t oxidize for obvious reasons, no oxygen. This is all anecdotal though and for most people, I think the tread of the tire wears out before the tire does from internal rot.
As for the nitrogen not reacting to temperature as much as compressed air, it’s probably a bit of snake oil magic going on there. At such low pressures, the nitrogen behaves like an ideal gas (just as oxygen and water vapor) so that means pure nitrogen will act just like regular air. A 0.5 mi/gal improvement in gas mileage is 1.6% improvement (on my car, which gets a little more than 30 mpg) which seems way too much.
It sounds like the “nitrogen is better than air” theory is not entirely true but since it costs me very little (if at all really) I won’t be complaining much about it. As long as you don’t pay for nitrogen, fill it with nitrogen; but if it costs you money, ask for regular air.
{ 161 comments, please add your thoughts now! }
Related Posts
 By Jim |
 Stumble It! Bookmark reddit.comTags: Cars, Costco Oct 20, 2005 | Read more in Shopping |
Like this article? Get all the latest articles sent to your email for free every day. Enter your email address and click "Subscribe." Your email will only be used for this daily subscription and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Ok, i think its funny seeing all these rediculous stories and people who are all so scared of something new. I work in a Costco tire center. We never make any outrageous claims as the ones that people are sworn they are told here. The only thing we claim is that nitrogen is more stable then air when it comes to CLIMATE CHANGE such as when the weather is hot, the air expands in the tires just as after driving on your tires. Or when its cold out and the air condenses in tires. The nitrogen WILL fluctuate, just no where near as much as normal air would. As many have said above, YOU STILL NEED TO CHECK YOUR PRESSURE REGULARLY! Nitrogen is just there to keep fuel consumption and tire wear to a minimum between intervals of checking tire pressure. Another thing, COSTCO HAS NEVER CHARGED TO PUT NITROGEN INTO YOUR TIRES! Nitrogen inflation was something decided to be done once there were “BENEFITS” to it being claimed. We modified our systems for the MEMBERS benefit. With it being free, whats the downside of putting pure nitrogen compared to normal air? It cant make it any worse so all there is is room for improvement. Now Stealerships and small shops charge for Nitrogen but COSTCO has never charged a single person for Nitrogen. And to finalize for all you worried people about mixing nitrogen and air, THERE IS NITROGEN IN AIR! 78% ACTUALLY! Mixing them together just reduces/nullifies the claimed benefits of pure nitrogen. BUT IT IS 100% SAFE TO MIX THEM! No less safe in ANY way then normal air.