In the discussions on Huckabee’s support of the Fair Tax , the idea of a value added tax (VAT), a type of consumption tax, was raised. here’s a discussion on how the VAT exists in the UK. It’s not to say that the UK’s version of a VAT is how every VAT is, but seeing as how our cultures are basically siblings, it’s not a bad thing to understand.
What is VAT?
In the UK, as in almost all of rest of the European Union, we have both an income tax, and a consumption tax – in the form of VAT. Like most taxes over in the UK, they are levied by central government and are used to fund both central and local government functions and services.
VAT is a “tax on the final consumption of certain goods and services”. From the point of view of the consumer, it is a lot like a sales tax – charged on the end value of the product. However, from the point of view of businesses, it is slightly different. Everyone only pays net VAT on the value that they have added to the goods and services. They do this by charging the consumer (which may be a member of the public, or another business) the full price of VAT, and claiming back the VAT on the supplies that they bought to make up the product or service.
Example of how VAT works
I buy £40 of raw supplies, I am charged £7 by the supplier in VAT, for a total of £47.
The supplier pays the £7 to the government.
I make a table with the supplies, and sell it to a customer for £100. I charge them £17.50 in VAT, for a total of £117.50
I pay the £17.50 to the government, and claim back the £7, leaving me with net VAT payable of £10.50
This difference between a sales tax and VAT means that you have to pay VAT regardless of whether you are the end user of the supplies, product or service or not. This means that it is in some respects harder to defraud, but also that there are greater administrative costs.
Information specific to the UK
Most goods and services in the UK have VAT charged at 17.5%, but there are three other rates, reduced rate (5%) and zero rate (0%) and exempt rate (no VAT charged) – there are technical differences between zero rated and exempt rated, but for most purposes they are identical.
In the UK, many essential items are either zero-rated or exempt from VAT – these include non-luxury food and drink, books, drugs, transport, buying most property, renting a home, medical care, postal services, financial products and many financial services, and clothing for children. Others are charged at the reduced rate, such as domestic fuel and tampons.
In addition, for many purposes charities do not have to pay VAT, nor do government departments (since VAT is an indirect tax, in practice I think they pay VAT via their suppliers and claim it back from the government).
As VAT is charged on in-country consumption of goods (technically, inside the EU) people exporting goods, either privately or in business, can claim back the cost of VAT paid. This means that foreign tourists may be able to claim back VAT from participating retailers – this voluntary scheme is usually only available on larger purchases (over £50-£100).
Attitudes towards VAT
Prices for most consumer goods are displayed with VAT incorporated into the price. This is especially true for smaller valued items. When Jim asked me if I’d write this post, I did ask around my friends to see if anyone had any opinions on VAT. No one seemed to care either way.
Consumer taxes that are more contentious are the so-called “sin taxes”, fuel duty and alcohol and tobacco duties. Fuel duty means that the price for petrol [gasoline] is currently running at $7 a gallon or more. The price of a bottle of wine in the supermarket starts at the equivalent of around $5-$6. These are reasonably unpopular predominantly because they are much higher than in other European countries; most Brits traveling abroad for their annual summer holiday [vacation].
I mentioned earlier that VAT is not charged on non-luxury food. Both cakes and biscuits [cookies] are deemed non-luxury items, but chocolate covered biscuits are luxury items. Jaffa Cakes are about the size and shape of say an Oreo, and made up a disc of semi-hard sponge cake, topped with orange jam [jelly] and chocolate. The manufacturers of Jaffa Cakes, McVities classified them as cakes, and were taken to a tribunal by Customs and Excise, who argued that they were in fact chocolate covered biscuits, and so liable for VAT.
McVities defended their case by making a very large Jaffa Cake in order to demonstrate that they really were just mini cakes. They also argued that biscuits go soft when left exposed to the air for long periods, and cakes go hard and since Jaffa Cakes go hard when left out, they were in fact cakes. McVities won their case, and VAT is not charged on Jaffa Cakes.